The CEO who ignored profit and beat the market


Hi Reader,

In 1987, a new CEO stood up in front of Wall Street's biggest investors and, as far as the room was concerned, lost his mind.

They had come to hear about margins, capital ratios and the plan for a company called Alcoa. Instead, Paul O'Neill said this:

"I want to talk to you about worker safety. I intend to make Alcoa the safest company in America. I intend to go for zero injuries."

One of the biggest investors there walked out and told his clients to sell everything. The board, he said, had put a crazy hippie in charge who was going to run the company into the ground.

He later called it the worst piece of advice he gave in his entire career. By the time O'Neill retired in 2000, Alcoa's annual net income was about five times what it had been, and the company was worth some $27 billion more than the day he arrived. He never once stood up to demand more profit. He chose one thing, and let it pull everything else up behind it.

Why safety, of all things

O'Neill understood something most leaders do not. You cannot order people to be more productive and make it stick. But you can unite a whole company around a single standard nobody can argue with, like not getting hurt at work, and use it to force the business to operate better.

Chasing zero injuries meant Alcoa had to fix everything around them. Hazards had to be reported the moment they appeared, so the walls between the factory floor and the executive suite came down. A machine that spills molten metal is dangerous, but it is also wasteful, so fixing the danger meant fixing the process. One clear standard dragged communication, accountability and discipline up with it.

That is a keystone. Pick the right one, and it carries the rest.

I watched this happen a few weeks ago

You do not need an industrial giant to see it. A few weeks ago I sat with a founding team working through exactly this question. Their keystone is not safety. It is NPS, how likely their customers are to recommend them.

On its own that is just a number on a dashboard. What makes it a keystone is that they run their decisions through it. What do we build next? Whatever moves NPS. What do we stop doing? Whatever does not. Where does the team's time go this quarter? Wherever the number is weakest.

It does the same work safety did at Alcoa. It gives everyone the same bar, it kills the arguments that used to go round in circles, and it quietly sorts the important from the merely urgent. The business is making better decisions, and you can watch it getting better because of them. Not because anyone is working harder, but because they are all pulling on the same thread.

Your keystone and your next hire

Here is where this reaches your hiring.

Once you have a keystone, every role can be defined against it. Not "we need a Head of Sales," but "we need someone who can move this number, in this part of the business, by this point." That one sentence does for your hiring what the keystone does for the company. It tells you what good looks like before you meet anyone. It forces the founders to agree. And it tells you honestly whether this is even a hire, or a problem you have decided to throw a person at.

Most hiring goes wrong long before the interview, because nobody did this. They chased the candidate instead of defining the outcome, and ran more interviews instead of answering the one question the whole thing depends on.

So here is the small version you can do this week. Name your keystone, the one number or standard that, if it moved, would mean the business is genuinely better. Then take the next role you are about to open and write down what that person has to do to move it, in their first year, with a date attached.

If you cannot, that is not a hiring problem. It is your keystone, and it is still missing.

Speak soon,
Konstanty

Thanks for reading! If you loved it, tell your friends to subscribe.

If you didn’t enjoy the email you can unsubscribe here.

To change your email or preferences manage your profile.

www.schoolofhiring.com

Hiring for Leaders: Become a Better Interviewer

With 20+ years of expertise as a founder & executive search professional, I share actionable strategies, tools, and insights to make hiring your competitive advantage.

Read more from Hiring for Leaders: Become a Better Interviewer

Hi Reader, I hear it from managers almost every week: "People just aren't motivated any more." "Nobody wants to work." "This generation is soft." I understand the frustration. But it is not that simple. I have sat through more than 12,000 interviews, and a lot of those candidates were explaining why they left their last job. Not one of them told me they got lazy. What they told me was something else. The same thing every time, just in different words. So I made a video about it. Five reasons...

Hi Reader, When you think about the things you are most proud of, how many of them were completely stress-free? Not many of mine. And the ones that cost me the most sleep were almost always about people. The senior hire I wasn't certain about. The good person I held on to far too long because letting them go felt brutal. The promotion I gave, and the one I held back. If you run a business, you know the feeling. A people decision carries a particular kind of stress, because you are deciding...

Hi Reader, Last month I spoke to a tech company that had posted an engineering role. Within a day, they had more than 500 applications. They interviewed six people and hired none of them. As far as I know, the listing is still up. There are more than 7 million job openings in the US right now, and CEOs say hiring has never been harder. And yet people under 25 are out of work at more than double the national rate. So everyone appears to be hiring, and nobody can seem to get a job. Most people...